
You bring a proposal to the department. Faculty want more discussion. The dean needs a recommendation. The semester schedule is already closing. Everyone agrees the issue matters, yet the next move remains unclear.
If you’re a department chair, you know this gap: responsibility lands in your office, while decision rights are distributed across faculty, the dean, committees, and policies. Your leverage comes from making those rights visible, and helping the right people make the right decisions.
A chair generally will not gain broader authority, and should not be handed blanket control over decisions that belong to faculty or the dean. The useful question is more precise: What can you decide, what must be decided together, and what has no named decision-maker yet?
That question creates momentum. It also gives a department a practical way to turn good ideas into shared action.
Why the chair’s role feels like a contradiction
Department chairs occupy a distinctive position. In Gmelch’s 2015 article, roughly 80% of university decisions are described as being made at the department level, citing Carroll and Wolverton (2004). Yet Gmelch also reports that 96% of chairs see themselves as faculty or faculty-administrators, while 4% identify as administrators. Many are expected to lead colleagues while remaining colleagues themselves.
The preparation gap adds to the strain. Gmelch reports that only 3% had systematic leadership development, drawing on a 1996 study, and cites research finding that just 3.3% of chairs arrived prepared for the role. A national UCEA study reported by Inside Higher Ed found that 67% of chairs received no formal training; among those who did, most had 10 hours or fewer, and two-thirds said their training did not adequately prepare them.
The California State University Department Chair Survey Report reports exactly: “69% report too much responsibility and too little authority.”
These figures describe a real pressure point. They do not make shared governance a problem to solve away. Good governance should help an institution decide. The chair’s work is to make the decision path clear enough for governance to do its work.
Gmelch calls the chair’s position “Janus”: facing both faculty and administration. In practice, that can mean translating a faculty concern into a dean-ready recommendation, then translating a dean’s constraint into a discussion the department can act on. The chair’s authority varies by institution and by issue. The task is to identify what’s already in the role, and forge the rest through clear agreements.
Three kinds of departmental decision
A decision map begins by sorting consequential questions into three categories. Use your institution’s policies, faculty handbook, and delegations of authority to confirm the local boundaries.
1. Faculty-owned decisions
These include matters such as curriculum, degree requirements, academic standards, and hiring recommendations. They are the terrain of shared governance: faculty bring disciplinary expertise, deliberate, and reach a recommendation or decision through the agreed process.
Your role is to make that process work. Clarify the question, frame the options, make sure the relevant voices are heard, and establish what happens after the vote or recommendation. The dean may hold final approval in some areas; the governance process still has a defined job to do.
2. Chair-owned decisions by delegation
When authority has been delegated to you, this category may include scheduling, teaching assignments, resource allocation within your remit, what goes to the dean, and what appears on the department agenda.
This is the category many chairs are surprised by. A chair may hold back out of care for colleagues and a desire to consult. Faculty may read that caution as indecision, especially when they assume the chair has already made the call or could make it.
Name the boundary. Explain what input you need, what you will decide, and when you will decide it. That clarity respects colleagues and honors your delegated responsibility.
3. Unmade or unassigned decisions
Here, the question is consequential, but no one has been named to decide it. People may be waiting for the chair, the dean, a committee, or a faculty vote. Each assumes someone else will take the next step.
This is where departments often lose time. The issue is a naming problem: the responsible decision-maker has not been named. The delay accumulates as Decision Debt: follow-up conversations, repeated agenda items, and work that cannot proceed.
The three categories bring the Spark and the Anvil into view. Faculty insight gives an idea its Spark; clear decision rights give it an Anvil strong enough to support action. The Forge is the work of bringing those two together.

What unclear decision rights look like in a department
A documented case makes the problem concrete. In their 2026 study of academic departments as sites of institutional governance, Riffe and Pifer describe a faculty search in a department without a written procedure. The conflict centered on whether candidates could be ranked and who had authority to call a vote. The dispute was about decision rights, not the candidates. Without a shared rule for how the search would move, participants could not reliably determine what action was available or who could initiate it. This is a naming problem: the process had left key authority questions unresolved. The case shows how an unclear decision map can stall important work even when the people involved are committed to doing it well.
The case matters because it moves the conversation away from diagnosing people as difficult or resistant. A search committee can be acting in good faith and still reach an impasse when the rules leave basic questions unanswered. The remedy starts with the actual decision: who can rank, who can call a vote, and what the department’s procedure says.
Shared governance is most useful when the route from deliberation to action is legible. For a search, that might mean documenting who develops criteria, how candidate evaluations are gathered, what the committee recommends, who can call a vote, and where the recommendation goes next. The institution’s own procedures determine the formal authority. The department’s map makes the working path visible.
A quiet failure often looks ordinary: another meeting, another request to clarify, another candidate waiting while the group revisits process. Naming the decision-maker gives the department a place to begin.
DIAGNOSE the decision before the meeting ends
Set aside 30 minutes in a department meeting. Choose one live issue that keeps returning to the agenda: a curriculum change, a search process, a resource decision, or a scheduling dispute.
Write the decision question at the top of a board or shared document. Keep it specific. “Improve the curriculum” is too broad. “Who decides whether the proposed course sequence goes to faculty vote this term?” can be mapped.
Then ask the group to sort the decision:
- Faculty-owned: What governance body or faculty process holds the decision or recommendation?
- Chair-owned by delegation: What exactly has been delegated to the chair, and what input is needed first?
- Unmade or unassigned: Which decision remains without a named owner?
For each item, record four things: the decision-maker, the people who advise or deliberate, the next action, and the date it will happen. If the group cannot agree on the formal authority, identify the policy or dean’s office that can clarify it. Avoid turning uncertainty into an informal rule.
End with the sentence that keeps the map practical:
This moves if ______ decides ______.
Fill in both blanks. “This moves if the faculty vote decides whether the new requirement goes forward.” “This moves if the chair decides the teaching assignments by Friday after reviewing faculty availability.” “This moves if the dean clarifies who may call the vote under the search procedure.”
The blanks force a useful distinction: who decides, and what are they deciding? A vague “we need alignment” becomes an actionable next step.

STRIKE the decision path into the work
A decision map should change the next meeting, not just describe the last one. Once the owner and decision are clear, put the work in motion.
For a faculty-owned decision, prepare a focused question and the information faculty need to deliberate. State whether the outcome is a recommendation, a vote, or another form of agreed action. For a chair-owned decision, specify what input you will consider and when you will make the call. For an unassigned decision, name who will clarify the authority and by what date.
This small discipline can save a department from repeating the same discussion without advancing the work. It also gives the dean a clearer picture of what requires approval, what belongs to faculty, and where a policy or delegation needs clarification.
A real strategy shows up in calendars, budgets, team behavior, and measurable results. For a department, that may mean a scheduled faculty vote, a named owner for a curriculum draft, or a decision on teaching assignments made before schedules lock. The proof is in what changes after the conversation.
EMBED the map in routine practice
The decision map becomes useful when it outlasts one meeting. Keep a short record of recurring decision types and the relevant policy or delegation. Add the decision-maker and next action to meeting notes. When a new chair takes office, hand over that map alongside the calendar and budget.
Deans can help by making delegated responsibilities explicit and clarifying where a chair should bring a question forward. Chairs can make governance easier by distinguishing between faculty deliberation and administrative decisions within their remit. Faculty members can help by agreeing on procedures that let their collective judgment reach a conclusion.
For a department deciding how to move a stuck idea, start with three questions:
- Who owns this decision under our governance and delegation rules?
- What specific choice or action must that person make?
- What happens immediately after the decision?
When the answer is uncertain, pause to clarify the authority. When it is clear, name the owner and move. That is how a department keeps careful governance and forward motion in the same room.

The chair’s map does not depend on accumulating more authority. It depends on making existing authority visible, protecting faculty-owned decisions, and naming the person responsible when a decision has no owner. That is the Forge: shared judgment meeting clear responsibility, until the department can move.
Sources
- Gmelch, W. (2015). “The Call for Leadership: Why Chairs Serve, What They Do, and How Long Should They Serve.” AKA Monographs, 1(1), 1–12. Full text
- Flaherty, C. (2016). “Forgotten Chairs.” Inside Higher Ed. Article
- Riffe, K. A., & Pifer, M. J. (2026). “Academic Departments as Microfoundations of Institutional Governance.” New Directions for Higher Education, 2026(213), 7–14. DOI
