
A cross-college initiative has broad support. The provost’s cabinet sees its value. Deans have begun working through implications. Faculty want a meaningful role. Months later, the same question is still circulating: Who can say yes?
When decision rights are unclear, the cost shows up in visible ways: priorities that never reach calendars, owners who cannot act, and approval steps that multiply without resolving the question. The idea may be sound. The institution may be ready. Yet the next move remains unnamed.
For a provost or dean, understanding decision rights in higher education means making authority and participation visible together. Who proposes? Who advises? Who decides? Who implements? Those answers create a path through governance, from a promising Spark to work the institution can carry on the Anvil.
The same decision problem repeats at every level
A department chair may be sorting which matters belong to faculty, which have been delegated, and which have no assigned decision-maker. At the college and university levels, the same triage returns with larger stakes: program investments, cross-college priorities, budget choices, new academic models, and institutional policy.
Titles alone rarely settle the question. A provost may be accountable for moving an academic priority forward while specific parts of the decision sit with faculty governance, a dean, a board, or a policy-defined review process. A dean may be responsible for a college’s results while authority over curriculum or faculty status follows established academic procedures.
This is where Decision Debt accumulates. Every unresolved authority question creates another meeting, another request for clarification, and another round of work that may need to be repeated. The Approval Tax is the time and attention spent moving through reviews whose purpose, role, or decision power is unclear.
The way through is to name the kind of authority involved. Shared governance gains force when participation is meaningful and the decision path is explicit.
Three kinds of decision rights to map
The AAUP’s shared governance guidance describes a joint responsibility among faculty, administration, and governing boards. It also says the weight of each group’s voice should reflect its responsibility and expertise. That principle points toward a practical map:
1. Assigned authority
A person or body has formal authority to decide within a defined scope. A provost or dean may hold delegated authority for a particular academic or operating decision. A faculty body may hold primary responsibility for academic matters such as curriculum, subject matter, teaching methods, research, and faculty status.
The local rules matter. Check the bylaws, faculty handbook, collective bargaining agreement, board policies, and delegations of authority. Then state the decision-maker and the boundaries of the decision in plain language.
2. Shared or consultative authority
Some decisions require faculty or other stakeholder participation because expertise, impact, or institutional policy demands it. Participation can take different forms: consultation, recommendation, concurrence, or joint decision-making. Each has a different meaning.
“Consulted” means a perspective must be heard. “Recommends” means a body advances a proposal. “Decides” identifies who holds the authority to make the call. “Must concur” sets a condition for action. A process moves more confidently when those roles are distinguished before deliberation begins.
3. Unmade or unassigned authority
Sometimes a proposal has a sponsor, a committee, and a schedule of meetings, but no one has been named to make the decision that unlocks the next step. People may be waiting for another level to act, while that level assumes a recommendation is still being formed.
This is the most overlooked source of organizational delay. The question is not only where authority sits; it is whether someone has actually been given the next decision.

A documented case shows why the map matters
A peer-reviewed 2023 case study by Jose Leonardo Santos and Matthew Filner examined shared governance at a public Midwestern university, identified by the researchers using a pseudonym. The researchers interviewed seven members of a task force formed after faculty raised concerns about decision-making and representation.
The study describes a practical challenge familiar to many academic leaders: faculty members participated in university councils, yet some felt their views were not shaping decisions. Administrators, meanwhile, faced overlapping committees and a process they experienced as difficult to navigate. The task force developed a framework that distinguished routine decisions from strategic, emergent, and crisis-related ones, with different levels of shared discussion for each.
The framework mattered because it made the decision type part of the conversation. A routine process could follow established procedures. A strategic or emerging issue could prompt broader governance discussion. The case also showed that a framework needs clear rules for applying it: participants still had questions about how to classify decisions and how the model would work in practice. Governance design creates momentum when it clarifies both the process and who applies it.
Read the case study in Learning and Teaching. It is a single institutional case, not a universal formula. Its useful lesson is the value of distinguishing decision types before the institution tries to move them.
DIAGNOSE the decision that is holding the work
Choose one initiative that has support but has not advanced. Keep the question concrete: “Who approves the shared advising model?” is more useful than “How do we improve student success?”
Write down five roles:
- Proposes: Who frames the option and brings it forward?
- Advises: Whose expertise or perspective must inform it?
- Recommends: Which body or leader advances a preferred course?
- Decides: Who has the authority to say yes, no, or revise?
- Implements: Who owns the next action once a decision is made?
Then verify the map against institutional policy. If two groups believe they hold the same authority, or no one can identify the decider, record that as the decision to resolve. Avoid treating an assumption as a delegation.
Ask the room: “This moves if ______ decides ______.”
The sentence brings authority down to a specific choice. It also gives the group a clean distinction between the idea under discussion and the decision that will unlock it. A useful diagnosis leaves you with a named decision-maker, a defined decision, and a date.
STRIKE a clear path from deliberation to action
Once the decision rights are visible, design the sequence. Put the right information in front of the right people at the right time. Make it clear whether a committee is developing a recommendation, a faculty body is exercising academic responsibility, or an executive is deciding within delegated authority.
A simple decision record can capture the decision, authority source, required participants, decision-maker, implementation owner, and next review point. That record reduces repeated debate and helps leaders explain how the process honors both expertise and accountability.
For a provost, this can sharpen cabinet conversations about cross-college priorities. For a dean, it can clarify which calls belong within the college and which require action or guidance from above. It also gives faculty a clearer understanding of how their deliberation connects to institutional action.
A real strategy shows up in calendars, budgets, team behavior, and measurable results. If a decision is made, the next meeting, resource allocation, owner, and milestone should reflect it. That is where the Anvil supports the Spark.

EMBED decision rights in the institution’s rhythm
One decision map can clear a bottleneck. A repeatable method helps prevent the next one.
For recurring decision types, document authority in the relevant policy or governance guidance. For novel decisions, name the person responsible for determining the process before the group invests months in discussion. When an urgent exception is used, specify its scope, duration, reporting, and review.
A university does not need every decision to move at the same speed. Academic judgment, institutional risk, resource commitments, and legal obligations call for different paths. The goal is to make those paths legible, so people can bring their expertise to the right point in the process, and know what happens next.
This is the 5th Hammer at work: SPARK gives the institution something worth moving; ANVIL gives it a reliable structure for decision and delivery; the FORGE joins both through clear ownership. We don’t choose. We forge.
The chair’s decision map applies the same discipline closer to the department: clarifying what faculty own, what has been delegated, and what still has no named decision-maker. At every level, momentum begins when someone can say exactly who decides what, and what the institution will do next.
